with Chitinase gene Developed Through Biolistic and Agrobacterium-Mediated
Transformation
N. Baisakh, K. Datta, N.P. Oliva and S.K. Datta
Plant Breeding, Genetics and Biochemistry Division, International
Rice Research Institute, MCPO Box
3127, 1271, Makati City, Philippines
Efficient genetic manipulation of
rice for agronomically important traits has been made possible by the transfer
of foreign gene(s) into the genome through either direct DNA transfer such
as biolistic or via Agrobacteri urn-mediated transformation. There has
been much debate on these two systems in terms of their efficiency and
the pattern of integration, mode of inheritance and stable expression of
the transgene(s). However, experiments dealing with both the systems keeping
all other factors, like target explants, gene(s) of interest, tissue culture
cycle, constant are lacking. We developed a large number of transgenic
rice plants from four to six week-old mature seed-derived callus of two
indica rice cultivars, vaidehi (suitable for deep water situation in eastern
India) and Tulsi (adapted to semi deep lowland condition), with an antifungal
PR-protein gene chitinase known to confer resistance against sheath blight
fungus. The vectors used were pGL235S- chill (Lin et a!. 1995) for bombardment
and LBA-pNol (Datta et al. 1999) for Agrobacteri urn-mediated transformation
carrying the same chill and hph (as a selectable marker gene) both driven
under the control of CaMV 35S promoter. From three experiments, we found
the net transformation frequency for both cultivars was higher in Agrobacterium
method as compared to biolistic. The Southern analysis of a total of 179
T0 plants of Vaidehi and Tulsi from Agrobacteriwn-mediated transformation
showed a single 1.1-kb size band expected for chill transgene (Fig. la),
whereas, multiple and rearranged bands apart from the expected size were
common in case of primary transgenics obtained from biolistic experiment
(Fig. ib). Further molecular analysis for.copy number showed one to three
copies of intact chill in Agrobacterium-derived plants while one to multiple
(> 10) with different molecular sizes were observed in the transgenics
from biolistic method. In the subsequent segregating generation (Ti), chill
was inherited in a typical Mendelian fashion with a ratio ~3:1 in the progenies
derived from Agrobacterium transformed plants suggesting single locus integration
of chill. On the contrary, both Mendelian (where there was single insertion
site) as well as non-Mendelian segregation (in cases of multiple and rearranged
bands) of chill were observed in the progenies of primary transgenics developed
through the biolistic method. Moreover, differrent banding pattern among
the progenies of biolistic-denved transgenics confirms the frequent possibility
of integration of multiple and rearranged copies of the foreign gene(s)
in more than one locus in the rice genome. This contradicts an earlier
report of single locus integration of multiple copies of a single gene
or multiple genes from biolistic experiment (Kohli et al. 1998). More details
of our study would be published elsewhere.
Immunoblot analysis revealed stable
expression of chill in the transgenics and their progenies by producing
an expected 35 kDa size protein apart from a 28 kDa size protein observed
in all the plants including non-transformed control, encoded by endogenous
chitinase genes present in the rice genome (Lin et al. 1995).
The transgenics developed from both
the cultivars via Agrobacterium-mediated transformation showed higher degree
of fertility whereas those developed through biolistic method showed very
high sterility in Tulsi, but not in Vaidehi. Since the possible role of
tissue culture induced variation among the transgenics was precluded keeping
all the tissue culture parameters identical throughout the experiment,
we presume cultivar Thisi to be highly sensitive to particle gun bombardment.
Interestingly, T1 progenies of three T0 lines of Vaidehi from Agrobacterium-mediated
transformation were short in height and had early maturity duration as
compared to control plants and those developed through biloistic method.
Detailed molecular analysis is in progress to characterize the plasmid
DNA- orl-DNA border-plant DNA junction to elucidate the precise integration
of transgenes in the genome accounting to variation in the expression level
and morphological-agronomic traits. Particle gene delivery system has been
favored and of wide use as genotype-independent method, but one can not
avoid the possibility of genotype-sensitivity to the physical trauma, multi-copy
or multinsite integration, rearrangements and chances of gene inactivation
due to homologous recombination or cosuppression. In our laboratory we
have successfully transformed several elite indica cultivars including
IR72, IR64, Basmati 122 employing Agrobacterium method (Datta et a!. Unpublished).
We strongly believe that with the availability of suitable vectors, and
optimized culture system, Agrobacteri urn method will have an edge over
other direct DNA delivery systems for its unique features where the integration
is simple with single to few copies of the T-DNA at the same locus thereby
diminishing the risk of expression instabilities resulting from further
recombination and silencing (Tinland 1996). Detailed insight into the molecular
mechanisms of integration, inheritance and stable expression without pleiotropic
effect of the transgene(s) is required with identical set up of the experiments
for more accurate and precise comparison of the methods of transformation
and their successful deployment in molecular breeding
Acknowledgement
This work has been generously supported by the Rockefeller
Foundation, USA and GTZ/BMZ, Germany.
References
Datta, K., Z. Koi&olikova-Nicola, N. Baisakh, N. Oliva and S.K. Datta, 1999. Agrobacterium- mediated engineering for sheath blight resistance of indica rice cultivars from different ecosystems. Theor. Appl. Genet (in press). Kohli, A., M. Leech, P. Vain, D. A. Laurie and P. Christou, 1998. Transgene organization in rice engineered through direct DNA transfer supports a two-phase integration mechanism mediated by the establishment of integration hot spots. Proc. NatI. Acad. Sci. USA 95: 7203-7208. Lin, W., C.S. Anuratha, K. Datta, I. Potrykus, S. Muthukrishnan and S.K. Datta, 1995. Genetic Engineering of Rice for Resistance to Sheath Blight. BioiTechnology. 13: 686-691. Tinland, B., 1996. The integration of T-DNA into plant genomes.
Trends in Plant Sci. 1(6): 178-184.
|