2. Studies on esterase isozymes in relation to origin and differentiation of cultivated rice

Hong-Wei CAI and Xiang-Kun WANG

Dept. of Agronomy, Beijing Agric. University, Ma-Lian-Wa, Beijing 100094 China

Esterase isozymes in rice have been investigated by a number of Chinese workers, although the use of different methods make it difficult to compare the results with one another. A trial comparison between results of various workers based on some distinct characteristics of bands is presented in Table 1.

We have examined a total of 1,270 strains of Asian landraces and the common wild rice (O. rufipogon), using sprouting seeds the extract of which exhibited all bands clearly. Electrophoresis was performed on polyacrylamide gel (PAGE) with Tris-citric acid buffer adjusted at pH 8.9. The conditions were 200V for 0.5 hour and 300V for 3 hrs at 4 deg C. The band running fastest was taken as 1A (10.5 cm from origin) as it was most clearly recognizable, and the band nearest the origin was numbered 14A (5.2 cm). Staining was made as follows: alpha and beta naphthyl acetate as main constituents of substrate, and fast blue RR salt as staining element. These were put together in 5 ml acetone, and the solution was poured into 100 ml phosphoric acid buffer adjusted at pH 6.4 to prepare the staining solution.

Table 1.  Comparison of esterase isozyme bands reported by different
          workers
______________________________________________________________________________
Present       Fu       Wu         Qian       Yu       Zhu       Nakaga-
author        Chu-Xia  Miao-Shen  Young-Wen  Wen-Jin  Yin-Guo   hra, M
______________________________________________________________________________
1A            7A       7A          12A         14A      13A       --
5A            6A       6A          --          12A      10A       7A
7A            5A       5A          9A          10A      7A        6A
8A            4A       4A          8A           8A      5A         -
10A           3A       3A          7A           7A       -         -
11A           3A       3A          7A           6A       -         -
13A           2A       -           -            -        -         -
14A           2A       2A          6A           -        -         -
______________________________________________________________________________
          
Table 2.  Frequency of esterase isozyme bands found in different varietal
          groups
_______________________________________________________________________________
Variety   No. of                 Frequency in   %
group     vars.  1A   2A   3A   4A  4aA   5A    6A    7A  8A  10A  11A 13A  14A
_______________________________________________________________________________
Hsien,     98    100  7.1  3.6  0   17.9  17.3  13.3 71.9 100  0   83.7 16.3  0
  India
Aus        34    91.2 8.8  4.4  0   35.3   0     8.8 97.1 100  2.9 17.6 79.4  0

Keng,      34    100  41.2 7.4 13.2 32.4   0    45.6 32.4 98.5 82.4 14.7 0  2.9
  India
Bulu       17    97.1 35.3 29.4 0   50.0   0    64.7 35.3 100  88.2 11.8 0    0

Tjcreh      6    100   0    0   0    0    66.7   8.3 33.2 100    0  100  0    0

Nuda      135    100  24.0 11.1 0.7 33.3   0.7  42.6 25.9 98.9 90.0 10.0 0    0

Hsien,     54    100   5.6  7.4 0    9.3  48.1   7.4 22.2 100    0  100  0    0
  China
Keng,      57    100  56.2 40.4 1.8 45.6   0    63.2  8.8 100  94.7  3.5 0  1.8
  China
O. rufi-   24    100  22.9  8.3 0   20.8   4.2  25.0 22.9 97.9   0   0   0  100
  pogon
_______________________________________________________________________________
The frequencies of bands 1A to 14A found in different varietal groups are shown in Table 2. Bands 1A and 8A were common to all the strains, with the exception of a few. 11A was characteristic of Hsien (Indica) varieties, with 5A as an auxiliary band. 5A was also frequent in Tjereh varieties of Indonesia. 13A was found only in Aus and some Inidan Hsien varieties. 14A was peculiar to the common wild rice, and was also found in a few Keng (Japonica) varieties of India and China. 10A was characteristic of Keng varieties, with 4aA and 6A as auxiliary bands. 4aA was stained black and differed in color from 4A and other bands which were stained red. It was frequent in Keng and Bulu varieties. Thus, the esterase isozymes were found to be useful for distinguishing between the Hslen and Keng types, although other diagnostic characters should also be taken into account for classifying Nuda (hairless), Rayada (long-duration deepwater rice) and other special varieties.

The genetic control of these bands was examined in 30 varietal crosses. Bands 11A, 13A and 14A were codominant and were dominant over 10A. These bands were controlled by alleles at a new locus which was found to be located on chromosome 1. We have designated this locus as Est-10 in addition to the nine loci for esterase listed by Morishima and Glaszmann (1990, p.52). Bands 5A and 7A were also codominant and were dominant over the null allele. These bands were controlled by alleles at Est-2 locus which is located on chromosome 6.

References

Morishima, H. and J. C. Glaszmann, 1990. Current status of isozyme symbols. RGN 7: 50-57.